Skip to content

Reading archive

Case Histories

by Kate Atkinson

Form
fiction
First published
2004
Edition
Penguin, 2015
Read
November 2026
Rating
10/10

A Muswell recommendation which absolutely delivered and left me wondering why I had never read anything by this prolific author previously. Case Histories had me gripped from the very first page. The novel opens with what could ostensibly by three short stories to do with seemingly unrelated crimes. Its main body then fast forwards to that of a retired police officer, now private investigator, trying to piece together the rationale for and perpetrator behind the prior events. Needless to say, all is not what it seems. Atkinson does a sterling job in drawing the reader in, mixing human suffering with laugh-out-loud moments of comedy. If this is a crime novel, then it is a very subtle subversion of one. Atkinson plays with and critiques the conventions of the detective genre. Traditional fiction may have a tendency to imply - falsely - that life has neat boundaries and endings, whereas reality is messy, continuous and ongoing. Life, quite explicitly for Atkinson, is inherently fragile. All the living characters are acutely conscious of their one mortality, with the 'balance sheet' of life forming another central theme. The genius, however, of Case Histories, lies in its emphasis on coincidence - lives overlapping (in)advertently without the characters even necessarily realising. Fate plays such an enormous role as Atkinson's reveals - to each of the three 'case histories' - show at the novel's end. I would happily reread and recommend.

By Kate Atkinson

Notebook manuscript

Original handwritten notebook page.
Original handwritten notebook page.